Showing posts with label trilogy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label trilogy. Show all posts

Friday, June 8, 2012

The Silence (Ingmar Bergman, 1963)



A group of three passengers, traveling in a train cabin that evokes the image of sweltering afternoon heat, are heading to an unknown city that is caught preparing for an impending war. A sickly translator, Esther, her sister Anna, a curvaceous woman preoccupied with corporal ambitions, and Anna's son Johan, an embodiment of purity. Suffering from a respiratory condition, Esther checks into a hotel room, while Anna and Johan occupying the adjacent suite. Soon, Esther's excessive attachment proves too suffocating for the sensual Anna, who walks out for a nightly adventure. The bedridden Esther overindulges herself with tobacco and alcohol in a vain attempt to subdue her loneliness. Johan is left to his own "strangeland" where he wanders through the near deserted hotel, encountering an elderly kindhearted hotel manager, and a band of dwarfs from a circus company. Johan who initially keeps a respectable distant from his ailing aunt gradually develops an empathy for her, drawn together by their mutual love for Anna and sense of solitude. On the final day of return, still unable to travel, Esther hands over Johan a letter containing a list of translations of foreign words for their journey. Anna and Johan leave behind ailing Esther in the desolate hotel and take a train homebound. The Silence is Bergman's last installment in his "God" trilogy, and arguably the most metaphysical and agnostic film of the trilogy. As Through A Glass Darkly equated human holiness with god, Winter Light analyzed spiritual bankruptcy, The Silence is an examination of emotional isolation in a world devoid of any God - where redemption lies in human connectedness the lack of which leads to wretched conditions. Allegorically, Esther has intelligent faculties at her disposal to communicate, but physical deficiency, fear of rejection by dear ones, and a sense of supremacy prevent her from being understood. Anna, on the other hand, perceives physical contact as a substitute for emotional intimacy, realizes the limitations of her understanding of communication, and is ultimately drawn to a state of emotional isolation. Johan's immature absorption of Esther and Anna's ideas leads him to tilt towards Esther, apparently. Bergman conveys alienation through spatial disconnectedness, partitioning physical space, darkness, sharp light angles, and scarcity of words. The use of mirrors creates a sense of distance between characters and the images in the mirrors further accentuate a sense of emptiness in characters. Note the scene that shows Esther observing Anna's reflection from the adjoining room as she washes her face, suggesting the ruptured intimacy between them. After a prolonged, asthma attack, Esther beseeches God to allow her to die in her own land. In the end, she is left behind by Anna and Johan to die in an abandoned hotel room in a strange land, Alone and forsaken:silenced by a conspicuous absence of God.

Thursday, June 7, 2012

Winter Light (Ingmar Bergman, 1963)





A communion is meticulously performed before a dwindling congregation: a school teacher, Marta, a troubled parishioner, Jonas Persson and Jonas' wife, Karin. But the religious ceremony has lost its significance for its message-bearer, pastor Tomas, who has a crisis of faith. Tomas's inner predicament is fittingly captured by a series of close ups, a characteristic of Bergman's cinematic signature. Tomas is callous and uncaring to the woman, Marta, who loves him. His interactions with Marta are mostly mechanical and ultimately acrimonious. When an apprehensive and suicidal Jonas seeks peace on a perceived imminent nuclear holocaust, equivocating Tomas offers his own uncertainty. Jonas gives in to the internal crisis, laden with faith, and commits suicide. The most bare and visually somber of Ingmar Bergman's religious trilogy, Winter Light, the second film of the trilogy, is a film in transition. It marks Bergman's final exploration of religious faith, or of the reasons to doubt the lack thereof, and serves as an overture to the psychological drama, the last part of his trilogy. Similar to Through a Glass Darkly, minimal cast, dialogue, and scenery suffuse the film, squeezing out the atmospheric tensions of the plot to its fundamental essence: God's silence. The unique use of monologues, elongated silences, and extreme close-ups convey emotional plights of the characters and paint a picture of emotional isolation. In perfect harmony are the barren landscape, seasonal climate, and Tomas' illness that further reflect the cold emptiness of his soul. In the final scene, Tomas returns to the obligation of the ceremonial communion attended by a meager  mass. Tomas is seen to minister the vacant words for those who solicit comfort from their lofty meaning, extract from them stamina for their spiritual solace and emotional composure.

Through a Glass Darkly (Ingmar Bergman, 1961)







Four figures come into focus from a water thin horizon, moving toward the shore of an apparently uninhabited island: David, a struggling writer, his adolescent son, Minus, his psychologically tenuous daughter, Karin, and Karin's husband, Martin. All the family members have gathered at the remote island in order to facilitate Karin's recovery from a previous nervous breakdown. David is the most self-absorbed character whose literary struggle has distanced him from his dear ones. David studies Karin with a clinical detachment of a psychological experiment. David is aware of his behavior and his emotional honesty and compunction is profoundly framed in a shattering scene where David cries uncontrollably in a dark room upon realizing how distant he and his children have grown. Martin is the least confused character who is visibly concerned with Karin's well-being, but fails to discharge his sexual energy due to Karin's convalescing conditions. Minus, the most virginal of all, is preoccupied with his own sexual awakening, and uses Karin as a convenient source of female psyche. Minus' emotional closeness to his sister is aptly captured by his plea to the God as he retrieves a blanket for Karin. Karin is the most religious, whose character is represented as an important link between religious devoutness and psychotic delusion. Like most Bergman films, Through a Glass Darkly is a sketch of emotional loneliness, social alienation, and the process of seeking of the God or love, as Bergman would propose.  Through a Glass Darkly is the first film of Ingmar Bergman's religious trilogy, in which the director, in my opinion, establishes the notion of God as a symbol of love, a savior during moments of personal emotional crisis. And this love exists in human connections and familial closeness. This basic theme is represented in the form of the character of David, who realizes after a botched suicide attempt that “God is love”.The film is visually frugal, dark, crisp, and sometimes allegorical. Karin's mental disintegration inside the hull of a shipwreck, symbolizes the tormented soul of Karin. It is a brooding and highly personal film for Bergman whose struggle with his own religious identity and upbringing are supposedly instrumental behind this creative effort. The film's essence is captured when David tells Minus: "I don't know if love proves God's existence, or love is God Himself." In the end, Karin sees God behind the closet door - a stony spider god - a painful allegory of her own family's illusory love.

Wednesday, June 6, 2012

A Film Trilogy by Ingmar Bergmann



In 1963 Bergman published the screenplays for Through A Glass Darkly, Winter Light, and The Silence in a single volume. In an introductory note the director gave his reasons for uniting the three films, a rationale that has influenced their reception over the past fifty years, Bergman wrote: "These three films deal with reduction. Through A Glass Darkly - conquered certainty. Winter Light - penetrated certainty. The Silence - God's silence - the negative imprint. Therefore, they constitute a trilogy." Film critics and historians absorbed this construct into their reviews and essays for years. In his 1969 analysis of Bergman's films, titled Ingmar Bergman, Robin Wood grouped the three films under the chapter heading " The Trilogy", without further mention of the concept. Others' greeted Bergman's statement more skeptically. Despite the fact that some critics felt the idea of a trilogy was rationalization after the fact, there is evidence that Bergman had considered the films a trilogy all along. Decades later Bergman recanted. In 1999, the director collaborated with film critic and friend Lasse Bergstrom to review all of his films. What resulted from these sessions is Images: a book of Bergman's personal reflections on his life's works. After almost thirty years of recognizing the trilogy as a trilogy, Bergman shifted his opinion: "Today I feel that the "trilogy" has neither rhyme nor reason. It was a Schnaps-Idee, as the Bavarians say, meaning that it's an idea found at the bottom of a glass of alcohol, not always holding up when examined in the sober light of day." Now film scholars, and Bergman's loyal audience are faced with the challenge of reconciling the director's two conflicting statements of intent, one made in the throes of creation, the other at a distance of decades. Despite Bergman's skepticism, however, the idea of the trilogy is permanenetly ingrained in the critical discourse that his work has inspired.

Sunday, June 3, 2012

The Silence (Ingmar Bergman, 1963)





Two women, Anna and Ester, accompanied by Johan, Anna's ten-year-old son, travel slowly through the night by train into a foreign country that seems to be at war. We will never discover the reason for their journey, to a place where the inhabitants, the culture, and the language are unknown to them. Perhaps it is to pare down or discard normal trappings of their lives, to take the consequences of who they turn out to be. In The Silence Bergman has shifted focus from God to people, from theology to psychology. But ideas are inert without visual expressions, and it is Bergman's genius to invite us, through extreme close-ups, to enter the mystery of people, of their faces. This preoccupation with faces, what they reveal and what they hide, is enhanced in The Silence. The unfathomable silence of the city has reduced the adults in the triangle to an almost zero level of communication with the outside world. Every personal connection is oblique and truncated, creating an ominous atmosphere in which gestures and symbols are often fugitive or vaguely menacing. For the young and curious Johan, wandering the corridors of the strangely vacant hotel, the brooding foreign city is merely the shell of an adult world whose impenetrable emotional climate is determined by his mother and aunt. Anna and Ester form two sides of a whole person. Anna is defined almost entirely through her physicality - washing, anointing herself with perfume and lotions, getting dressed and undressed, having sex, watching others have sex. Ester, the translator, with her typewriter, paper, and pens, is instead a creature of languages - suffering from the lung disease that suffocates her, masturbating, smoking, drinking, and thinking of sex as a mechanical matter of "erections and secretions" that disgust her.  Her body in ruin, only words have seem to kept her alive. Amid the noise, music, and silence that layer the soundtrack, Anna and Ester are locked in a cryptic struggle that plays out before Johan's eyes and in his feelings. The lessons of life are to be learned from the lives of women. Although we see many things that he does not, Johan is the spine of the film. It is the movement of his sympathies from his seductive mother to his intellectual, ailing aunt that gives coherence and force to Bergman's meditation on human frailty.

Sunday, May 20, 2012

Roberto Rossellini (1906 - 1977)










Roberto Rossellini is considered as one of the architects of Italian Neo-realism. Of all the films that he made, Rome, Open City (1945), Paisà (1946), and Germany Year Zero (1948) are considered his masterpiece. Rome, Open City (1945) is about a city, Paisà (1946) is about all of Italy from the south to the north, and Germany Year Zero (1948) is about a great country that has been conquered and destroyed. François Truffaut (The Films In My Life, p. 276, 1978) wrote the following about Rossellini's  style: "Rossellini detest clever titles, especially with scenes preceding them, flashbacks, and everything in general that's included simply for decoration, everything that does not serve the film's intention or the character development."