The story of Brokeback Mountain a familiar one. Ennis Del Mar and Jack Twist are two cowboys who are hired by Joe Aguirre to shepherd sheep up on a Wyoming mountain named Brokeback. After a half hour of lushly scenery, Jack takes Ennis seduces Ennis and within seconds, Ennis is inexplicably battering Jack. Inexplicably because, a few scenes earlier, Jack was cooking and Ennis stripped naked to bathe, and neither man takes mind of what the other is doing. This gives an impression of instant gays, which is utterly absurd. In one of the reuniting scenes later, they practically bite off each other’s lips, indicating the extent of passion. Is this real? In the film, neither actor emits chemistry with nor eros for the other. Decades go by, and these two men marry, use, and abuse the women in their lives. Ennis is the worse of the two, for his wife Alma actually seems to love him, while Jack’s wife, Lureen, a former cowgirl, accepts the fact that he’s queer, and is romantically involved with Ennis in Wyoming. The wives are mere plot points in the film, not worth developing, especially since the leads are left in emotional utero even longer. The two male leads, however, look ridiculous in their poor makeup jobs. Aging, for them, consists of growing sideburns, it seems. Eventually, Ennis divorces his wife and Jack goes ‘full on’ in his quest for sexual quest, which eventually gets him to death at the age of thirty-nine. The best scene in the film is when Ennis calls Jack’s wife, after a postcard comes back marked deceased. Gyllenhaal is ok as Jack, but Heath Ledger totally butchers ‘cowboy’ lingo, constantly letting his Aussie accent seep through his near constant mumbling. On a social level, I am tired of films like this that indulges more gay stereotyping by making gay characters dying, murderous, depressed, deranged, victimized, or victimizer. And, ethically, the film does a lot of dancing around the ethics of adultery and lying in a marriage. For example, if this film were about two men who cheated on their wives with other women, would the film have portrayed their encounters so favorably? But, adultery is okay if gay, and letting your ‘true’ self be revealed. So, it’s ok to be a liar if queer, but if you lie and use women in your straight adultery it’s not ok? Brokeback Mountain is not a love story for the ages, but a tale of simple sexual obsession. This film simply subordinates whatever good artistic impulses the director may have had in favor of the Lowest Common Denominator import of the ‘message’. Were this a film whose leads were straight, the critics would have torn at it for being every bit as kitschy as the abominable Love Story was. Bad writing, and dubious moralizing, makes Brokeback Mountain every bit as bad a film as any other bad film.
The director is the only person who knows what the film is about - Satyajit Ray (Our Films Their Films, 1994)
Showing posts with label romance. Show all posts
Showing posts with label romance. Show all posts
Wednesday, July 18, 2012
Brokeback Mountain (Ang Lee, 2005)
The story of Brokeback Mountain a familiar one. Ennis Del Mar and Jack Twist are two cowboys who are hired by Joe Aguirre to shepherd sheep up on a Wyoming mountain named Brokeback. After a half hour of lushly scenery, Jack takes Ennis seduces Ennis and within seconds, Ennis is inexplicably battering Jack. Inexplicably because, a few scenes earlier, Jack was cooking and Ennis stripped naked to bathe, and neither man takes mind of what the other is doing. This gives an impression of instant gays, which is utterly absurd. In one of the reuniting scenes later, they practically bite off each other’s lips, indicating the extent of passion. Is this real? In the film, neither actor emits chemistry with nor eros for the other. Decades go by, and these two men marry, use, and abuse the women in their lives. Ennis is the worse of the two, for his wife Alma actually seems to love him, while Jack’s wife, Lureen, a former cowgirl, accepts the fact that he’s queer, and is romantically involved with Ennis in Wyoming. The wives are mere plot points in the film, not worth developing, especially since the leads are left in emotional utero even longer. The two male leads, however, look ridiculous in their poor makeup jobs. Aging, for them, consists of growing sideburns, it seems. Eventually, Ennis divorces his wife and Jack goes ‘full on’ in his quest for sexual quest, which eventually gets him to death at the age of thirty-nine. The best scene in the film is when Ennis calls Jack’s wife, after a postcard comes back marked deceased. Gyllenhaal is ok as Jack, but Heath Ledger totally butchers ‘cowboy’ lingo, constantly letting his Aussie accent seep through his near constant mumbling. On a social level, I am tired of films like this that indulges more gay stereotyping by making gay characters dying, murderous, depressed, deranged, victimized, or victimizer. And, ethically, the film does a lot of dancing around the ethics of adultery and lying in a marriage. For example, if this film were about two men who cheated on their wives with other women, would the film have portrayed their encounters so favorably? But, adultery is okay if gay, and letting your ‘true’ self be revealed. So, it’s ok to be a liar if queer, but if you lie and use women in your straight adultery it’s not ok? Brokeback Mountain is not a love story for the ages, but a tale of simple sexual obsession. This film simply subordinates whatever good artistic impulses the director may have had in favor of the Lowest Common Denominator import of the ‘message’. Were this a film whose leads were straight, the critics would have torn at it for being every bit as kitschy as the abominable Love Story was. Bad writing, and dubious moralizing, makes Brokeback Mountain every bit as bad a film as any other bad film.
Monday, April 30, 2012
The Scent of Green Papaya (Anh Dung Tran, 1993)
The film was nominated for an Oscar in 1994.
Sunday, April 15, 2012
Three Times (Hsiao-Hsien Hou, 2005)
Hou Hsiao-Hsien, a celebrated filmmaker from Taiwan, presents a romantic drama in his own style - gentle pacing and magnificent visuals that are worth a thousand word. The film boasts of three sublime love stories that are separated by time but unified by the same male-female lead actors. The faces are kept the same (Shu Qi and Chang Chen) across time periods so as to suggest the immortality of love? To suggest that the prototypical characters in love never change only the contexts keep redesigned by socio-political circumstances? The first story A Time for Love takes place in 1966 when a young soldier falls in love with a pool hall hostess. The boy awaits a war deployment that comes at the expense of his blossoming romance. The girl keeps changing towns in-between to earn her livelihood. A parade of love letters communicate their feelings for each other that comes to its fruition at the end. Hsiao-Hsien's perfect framings and apt choice of the sound tracks (Aphrodite Child's "Rain and Tears" and Platters' "Smoke Gets in Your Eyes") recreate the magic of In the Mood for Love (2000) by Kar Wai Wong. The setting of the second story A Time for Freedom is 1911 when the Chinese Revolution led to the overthrow of the Qing Dynasty. Hsiao-Hsien presents the story as a silent film, in accordance with the background of the film. The boy who is a regular visitor to a brothel wants to start a newspaper and be on the frontline of the on-going freedom struggle. The girl is a prostitute in the brothel who languishes in love for the boy and awaits freedom. Communications between them are established by scarcely dispersed letters. While the boy is all warmed up for the freedom struggle, he fails to see through the servitude of the girl which can be broken by only him.Love remains unfulfilled in a world where individual freedom is engulfed by desire for collective liberation. The modern day story named A Time for Youth is set in 2005 Taiwan.Here a bi-sexual woman is slowly nearing death but is caught in two romantic affairs, with a photographer and a teenage girl. The characters have all the modern means of communication (the computers and cell phones) and still struggle to communicate in the language of love. Their selfish infatuation with the modern day gadgets only take them away from each other. Love desperately searches for a humane language in a selfish world of machines. The stories have no deep and multi-layered messages as one would expect from such cinematic endeavors.The subtext is simple yet profound and is mostly captured by silent gestures and moments of contemplation. Of the three stories, the first one stayed with me much after the last light had awakened. It is the purity of love and romantic innocence that will once again cast their magical spell on you.
The film was nominated for the Palme d’Or at the 2005 Cannes Film festival.
Saturday, March 31, 2012
In The Mood for Love (Kar Wai Wong, 2000)
In the Mood for Love is the second part of Hong-Kong-based director Wong Kar-wai’s trilogy, along with Days of Being Wild and 2046. The three films is a reflection on time, memory and relationships.The film takes us to Hong Kong in the early 1960’s, when two neighbors move into a very busy building. Mrs. Chan and Mr. Chow start a friendly relationship, which becomes increasingly intimate when they discover that their respective spouses are cheating on them, actually with each other. The shared pain of unfaithfulness brings the two forlorn hearts closer and a unique bond of love blossoms between them. The film while dealing with an extramarital relationship never leaves you with the impression that the duo indulges in the same wrongdoing that their respective spouses are charged with. Taking a sensitive topic such as marital infidelity and making a poetic love story out of that is not an easy feat for any director. The film is filled with close-up shots, voyeuristic camera movements, minimal usage of lighting, and use of shadows and reflections that accentuate the tiny details of daily life of the two protagonists and thus intensify the romantic moments. The film features one of the most routine scenes about lovers: two lovers in a slow motion, but these scenes are infused with so much artistry with a nuanced sense of music that they end up creating long-lasting impressions in the viewers' mind. The shots of narrow corridors, streets, and staircases highlight a sense of secrecy and confidentiality of the characters, and at the same time underscore the agony of alienation of the characters. The plot is developed aesthetically and is aurally supported by the repetition of the sublime theme song. This music and the visual rhythms of the film force us to feel the unspoken desires of a couple yearning to be together. Mrs. Chan is shot like a great painter. The audience sees her the way she is viewed by her neighbor. She manages to combine the feeling of a betrayed, lonely, and subtly sensual woman. Dialogue is relegated to a trivial role and is replaced by suggestive body languages, eye contacts, and delicate breathing. This is the language that reveals the couple’s inner thoughts. The respective spouses are always distanced from the viewer to stress the distance between the protagonists and their spouses. The film ultimately leaves us with questions like would the cheated couple engage in an affair with each other and become a double of their spouses? This is for us to wonder. Wong Kar-wai merges a simple and potentially scandalous story with an artist's mind, and thus creates a masterpiece of cinema in the process. In the Mood For Love elevates a simple love story to an exceptional aesthetic altitude that goes far beyond a familiar plot of relational complexity. This stylized romantic film addresses relationships from a measured distance, but a distance that can only be created by a true artist.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)







